Friday, June 28, 2013

The Madman

Book: The Madman
Author: Kharil Gibran
Edition: Gutenberg eBook
Read: June 2013
58 pages
Rated: 3 1/2 out of 5

Synopsis:
This is one of the lessor known books of Gibran. It is a book of parables about a person whose mask had been removed by thieves. He can now see clearly and is a madman. So he tells stories about the truths he tells.


Thoughts:

It is better to tell stories with meaning than to say so plainly. With a story, the listener gains understanding. With direction, only a law.

One story (TheWise King) which struck me told how a whole city had gone mad overnight, except for the king and his advisor. This was because their well had been poisoned. The people started whispering that the king was mad, should he rule?  In this short story, Gibran opens up a whole realm of questions. What is the nature of madness? How can a person rule his subjects which think he is unfit? 

Or in The New Pleasure, he shows how thin a difference virtue and vice, sin and goodness can be. CS Lewis would say that sin would only be corrupted pleasure. Or in The Three Ants, he explores what we know and how our ignorance leads us into disaster.

The Blessed City talks about a city which has the reputation for righteousness. When the traveler comes to it, he discovers the population is missing their right hand and eye. When he attends a time of instruction, he understands the lack of hands and eyes and their righteousness. He then flees the city. Read the story and find out why.

More stories along the same lines. Some of them I do find wise. Most I do not.

Evaluation:
 This writing is one which provokes thinking. Unlike The Prophet which is more explicit, Gibran relies on story images to convey his thoughts. He is mostly effective in his story telling. There are a few stories which lack ths qualities, but that may be due to something in the reader.  Such as the Scarecrow saying only those who are stuffed with straw can have the joy of scaring. A year later, two crows were making a nest in his head. Interesting on both parts.


This is the type of book which I like to read-simple, but raises profound questions.



Contents:
Good Quotes:

  • First Line:  You ask me how I became a madman
  • Last Line:  Why am I here, O God of lost souls, thou who art lost amongst the gods?
  •  And I have found both freedom of loneliness and the safety from being understood, for those who understand us enslave something in us.  2


References:

Thursday, June 13, 2013

Things Fall Apart

Book: Things Fall Apart


Book: Things Fall Apart
Author: Chinua Achebe
Edition: 50th Anniversary Edition
Read: June 2013
238 pages
Rated: 4 out of 5

Synopsis:
Achebe tells the story of a young Nigerian who grows up under a disgrace of a father, vowing never to be like him. The story follows Okonkwo's rise in his own clan to being rich, famous and powerful. It being only a matter of time before he becomes great. Then an accidental death occurs forcing him to flee from his village to the village of his mother.  As he waits out his seven years there, he plans out his glorious return.

Except, the entry of the white man and his religion causes unexpected chaos in not only his father's village, but into his mother's village, reaching all the way to the conversion of his own son. The story then shows the confusion of Okonkwo and the tragic results.

Evaluation:
 Achebe tells a story of a young pre-colonial Nigerian. The first half to two thirds of the book plods along. I could not figure out what Achebe was trying to do with it. The assumption is that I did not understand the African cues which Achebe was giving because I could not see them. Little did I know that Achebe was laying the groundwork for my understanding of the last part of the book.

When the whites come into the picture, there is a mixture which Achebe wants me to understand. He understands the customs, the fears, the superstitions which in almost any society today is abhorrent. The killing of twins, the abandonment of a wife who has outlived her usefulness, the brutality which allows for a person to kill another whom he has treated as a son in cold blood—all of which Achebe lays before the reader. He shows how the white man's religion came in and drew upon those who felt they were outcasts and brought them in.

But Achebe also saw that the white man also came with arrogance, with his sense of superiority over the Africans. In many, not all, there was not the love their religion had taught them for their fellow man. Instead, the Africans were treated as objects, to be discarded or beaten if they did not prove to be useful.

It is in Achebe's main character where all of this meets up. The man could not cope with the changes. He riles against them. When he sees his fellow villagers being resigned to be ruled over, he rebels until he cannot take it no more and brings about his ultimate disgrace.

All of this makes for a book to read and ponder over. To think about how we do not rightly understand those who are different. What is good which we bring to others? What hidden faults to we bear? These are the questions of Achebe.


Notes from my book group:
The group generally liked it. There was a wide ranging discussion on the book, even on a pot luck night—these discussions tend to be more low key. The thoughts expressed included how  Okonkwo was shaped by his reaction to his father, how he could not adjust to changes in his culture, the impact of the white man's coming, and how little regard there was for low-class people in that society.


Good Quotes:
  • There is no story that is not true. (141)

References:

Thursday, May 9, 2013

The Unlikely Pilgramage of Harold Fry

Book: The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry
Author:Rachel Joyce
Edition: Read on Overdrive
Read: April 2013
684 pages
Rated: 4 out of 5

Synopsis:
Harold Fry gets a letter and sets out on a walk-across England. During his walk, he meets a cast of characters, which makes him realize what he has back at home and what mistakes he has made along the way. At the end, he understands himself and his place better. He no longer is concerned about losing what he has, but embraces what he has.

Thoughts:

Why do modern writers, even when they have a good story, feel the compulsion to degrade their story with language which is more suited to the gutter? In this story, there is nothing added because of it.

From the start, Joyce writes about things which are lost: making your wife laugh, the replacement of consideration with nagging, the loss of friendship and the loss of one's son. But Fry as he goes on his 600 mile walk gains understanding and insight into himself and others. He gains a strength of character which overcomes many of his doubts about himself.

There is also a sense of delusion.but part of the skill which Joyce has is her ability to not let you know where the delusion is coming from. Is Fry deluded in thinking he can save Quenee by walking? Is Maureen deluded in thinking that talking to her son will solve her problems? By the way, why don't we ever see their son in the book-you find out why later in the book.

Not knowing what to say to a dying women-a common problem. Maybe Joyce has hit --upon something, it is action which will cause a sense of empathy.  Even to his wife, Fry does not know what to say to express himself. But as we find out, it is own clumsiness with worlds which causes people to be attracted to him.

Irony-I will be back soon in chapter one. Did Fry know he was going for a long walk?

 Joyce says that as a boy, Fry instinctivily distrusted the world he did not know. (chp 2) You had the impression this was both  a sense of geography and relationships.

Joyce seems to be saying that with faith you can do anything (chp 2). But faith in what? She really does not say. She does not even say that faith  has to have an object. In this sense, it is rather ill-defined. It sounds more like platitudes than wisdom. Such as believing you can make a difference. While true, this has at least some substance. You hae to go out and walk this belief, so to speak.

In chapter two, he talked about the things in life which he had let go. It was not the large things, but the small-smiles, offers of beer, not making contact with people, neighbors. This is a book where Harold Fry trys to make a difference after realizing he has lost those small things. 

When Harold retires, one of his co-workers says that he heard that Harold has a story(39), but he does not know what it is. This just reminds me that each of us does have a story and we need to understand first, what our story is. But then also what someone else's story is. How our stories get interwoven together.

Every great adventure has a sense of doubt. Not so much in if something is achievable, but in the doubt that we are up to the adventure. For us humans, it is the sense of our own inadequencies. For Fry, it is he has never walked, the voices of doubt from his wife, the looks of strangers.

Fry becomes a minimalist. He gives away what he does not need for now. He becomes free that way. Is this a true expression? Can you continue like that for more than a relatively short time? Can this be applied to all? I think that there is too much dependence on others for such a thing to be large. It is delusional--which Fry never advocates--to think that everybody should what Fry is doing. But there is a certain amount of benefit to doing short-term minimalistic trips. Such as after going backpacking for an extended length of time, I realize that I can do without a large amount of stuff in my life.

For the most part, Harold Fry does his journey alone, and he likes it that way. Along the way, he will meet people, talk with them. But for the most part, they are temporary relationships. But at one point he unwittingly acquires fame. At this point he starts to aquire an almost circus like following. Fry does not like this, but is too meek to turn anybody away. He does not think of himself as a leader of a movement, but as an individual which others happen to latch onto. One particular needy person, Wilf, latches onto Fry. Wilf reminds Fry of his son, complete with the needs his son had. Fry realizes that as he could not save Wilf, he could not save his own son.

One of the joys of Joyce's writing is she has many interesting phrases:
  • beating out wasted time (the man with keys on the counter)
  • faces appeared fixed as if joy had been squeezed away (office workers)
  • Old people should retire and sit at home (thought which Fry had on the first morning)
  • He had started, and in doing so Harold could see the end. (As Fry was leaving the first morning.)
  • How fast and angry the cars seemed when you were not in one of them. (Second morning walk)
  • We all have a past (barman on second day)
  • He was one of those who did not need anybody else to hold a conversation (the walking man)
  • He hoped they were not one of those couples who voiced in public what they could not voice at home.  (About walking man and his wife)
  • In the city, where everything was short-sighted (upon enter Exeter)
  • In the city, Harold's thoughts had stopped...(upon leaving Exeter)
  • She had stayed because, however lonely she had been with Harold, the world without him would be even more desolate. (Maureen after doctors visit)
  • It was as much of a gift to recieve as to give, requiring as it did both courage and humility. (256)
  • I have come to think we sit more than we're supposed to. Why else would we have feet? (262


Evaluation:
  Rachel Joyce has a good story about an ordinary man whom life has beaten down. But he decides to do something ordinary, like walking with the belief it was save a friend. She tells this story from a vantage point where you empathize with Harold Fry and want to understand more about him.

The start of the book is her strongest. She takes you through a series of characters whom Fry listens to, each leaving with a sense of a bit more understanding. These little stories could be individual short stories-she was a writer for BBC Radio, Channel 4. It is the middle to late part of the book where I found the stories chaotic and a bit repulsive. Joyce may have meant it that way. She ties all of the strings back together again at the end, making the story complete and understandable.

Joyce's story caused me to think a bit more about the ordinary things in life and how special you could make them. While it can be a bit sappy, walking to save a person, it does provide context and purpose to Fry's life. It is also a story of reconciliation-reconciliation with Fry's wife and with himself. This is a story of faith, a faith which grows as he walks.

Is it a book worth reading? Yes. First to help you feel good. Second to understand that you can make some difference to someone, even if it in small ways. 

 
Notes from my book group:

  1. Val, how did you come across this book? Why did you think it would be a good book for us to read?
  2. Why does Fry go for a walk? Why was Harold so motivated to see Queenie? Was Fry running away? If so, from what?
  3. In Chapter 2, there is a dialogue between Harold Fry and the girl in the garage. What is the girl's faith in? Does it matter what her faith is in? How does this talk inspire Harold Fry?  Does it matter that later on in the book, she reveals that her aunt died anyway?
  4. How does the story reveal Fry's personality? His relationships and his fears? How did Fry's upbringing or lack of it, affect how he turned out? His trouble with his own son? Did this lead to his son's suicide? Why couldn't Fry go to say goodbye to his son? Is Joyce's thoughts about Fry's upbringing universally true?
  5. Fry relies on the goodwill of strangers. Do you think this would happen? How would you react to his story?
  6. What kind of woman was Maureen? How does this shape Fry and his desire to see Queenie? How does his love for Maureen get reshaped through the walk?
  7. Joyce has Maureen say that Harold never did the unexpected (chp 3). How is this? Why? Is doing the unexpected a sign of being alive? Being predictable, signing of being a machine? How does a person stop living? 
    1. Awareness
This story is really a form of Harold Fry coming of age--late in life.
See Orwell's Down and Out in Paris and London

New Words:
  • Tessellations(52):  A tessellation of a flat surface is the tiling of a plane using one or more geometric shapes, called tiles, with no overlaps and no gaps. In mathematics, tessellations can be generalized to higher dimensions.  Think of a M.C. Escher drawing.
  • Masticate(59):  to grind or crush (food) with or as if with the teeth
  • Dartmoor Trail (97):  Apparently not a real trail, but there are several trails in the area
  • Cotswold Trail (97): The Cotswold Way is a 102-mile (164 km) long-distance footpath, running along the Cotswold Edge escarpment of the Cotswold Hills in England
  • Spiraea (128): genus of about 80 to 100 species[3] of shrubs in the family Rosaceae.
  • Holdall (243):  similar to a gym bag but may often have wheels and possibly a telescopic handle. The term covers a wide variety of types of bag.
  • Morris dancers (263): form of English folk dance usually accompanied by music. It is based on rhythmic stepping and the execution of choreographed figures by a group of dancers, usually wearing bell pads on their shins

Good Quotes:
  • First Line:  the letter that would change everything arrived on a Tuesday.
  • Last Line: They stood at the water's edge, not letting go , and rocked with laughter.
  •  If you don't go mad once in awhile, there is no hope. (47)
  • Life is very different when you walk through it. (57)
  • Maybe you saw even more than land when you got out of the car and used your feet. (60)
  • Tourists bought trinkets and souvenirs at religious places because they had no idea what else to do when they got there. (111)
  • He no longer saw distance in terms of miles. He measured it in terms of memories. (127)
  • The past is the past; there was no escaping your beginnings, (178)
  • He had a different map, and that was the one in his mind, made up of all the people and places he had passed. (256)
  • He saw that when a person becomes estranged from the things they know, and is a passerby, strange things take on a new significance. (256)
  • The people met, the places he passed, were all steps in his journey, and he kept a place in his heart for each of them. (260)
  • Nobody is so frightening once you stop and listen. (273)
  • If we can't accept what we do not know, there really is no hope. (399)

References:

Monday, April 29, 2013

A Study in Scarlet

Book: A Study in Scarlet
Author: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
Edition: Gutenberg
Read: April 2013
178 pages
Rated: 4 out of 5

Synopsis:
Dr. Watson, meet Mr. Holmes, and the Bake Street Irregulars. Doyle introduces us to both of these characters, with Holmes ability to analyze and work back to the origins, and Watson's ability to be baffled by his friends abilities.

Two men are murdered with the London police chasing after the wrong clues. Holmes solves and catches the murderer in front of the detectives. But that is only half of the story. Doyle goes on and tells why, through the mouth of a third party and the eyes of the murderer. While Holmes does not visit Utah, the reader does and gets exposed to some of Doyle's views on Mormonism.

Thoughts:
Did Dolye visit the States? How and where did he get his information on Mormonism? How accurately does Doyle portray the LDS church of this time? About the same time, I read Jon Krakauer's book, Under the Banner of Heaven. There was a lot of similarities of what Krakauer said with how Doyle portrayed this period LDS history.

From what I have read, Doyle did not visit Utah. But was retelling the common rumors of the day concerning Mormonism. Doyle's dauhter thought that her father would say this was a work of fiction and there was all kinds of errors concerning Mormonism. 

The portrayal is a religion which is a law to itself. It is us against them. If you are not part of us, then there is not a concern for you. Also if you turn your back on the faith, you are a deadman. As Krackauer presents things, this is due to the persecuted the LDSchurch faced.

This plays into the plot line of the book. Vengeance leads to murder. But the vengeance is because of an older murder. Doyle explores how vengeance takes over a man's life. This vengeance compels a man across a continent and an ocean. But it does not leave the man in peace, only having a purpose.

Holmes is interesting in that he has a very mechanical, logical mind. There is vast stores of knowledge stored in his brain, but of limited scope-such as geology and botany. But he does not have too much knowledge of literature or music, except for the violin he plays. What does this say about Holmes. He able to deduce the socks off of anybody, but does he enjoy himself? Is he really experiencing being fully human?


Evaluation:
This is the original Sherlock Holmes book. It is entertaining and a delight to read. Watson becomes much than just the Holmes biographer; you see him as someone who has confronted danger on his own. But you also see a lot more rawer version of Holmes. Holmes does not have the polish he has in later mysteries. But you learn of his background and why he has the relationship with the police he has.

This is a good and enjoyable read. You will neither be scarred for life by it, or heighten your sense of awareness after reading A Study in Scarlet. But you have have gotten a couple hours of enjoyment.  You could do a lot worse.

 
 
Good Quotes:
  • First “IN the year 1878 I took my degree of Doctor of Medicine of the University of London, and proceeded to Netley to go through the course prescribed for surgeons in the army.
  • Last Line: “In the meantime you must make yourself contented by the consciousness of success, like the Roman miser—”
  • “To a great mind, nothing is little”. Part I, Chp IV, page 73 

References:

Monday, April 8, 2013

Same Kind Of Different Me

Book: Same Kind Of Different Me
Author: Ron Hall, Denver Moore with Lynn Vincent
Edition: 2006, 1st Edition
Read: March 2013
235 pages
Rated: 3 out of 5

Synopsis:
Ron Hall is an art dealer who got rich by falling into the profits of selling art. In a different turn of events he and his wife Deborah would have been on the streets-that is if his initial gamble had fallen through. Instead, he lived very comfortably amongst the upper crust of Ft Worth society.

Denver Moore was born and raise in the plantations of Louisiana. As a black, there was no way to escape from the sharecropper life, except to runaway. That is what he did, winding up in Ft Worth, living on the streets 30-40 years, with a stint in the worst of Louisiana's prison. He was feared on the streets.

Deborah was Ron Hall's wife, the one who was in tune with God. God gave her a vision for a work she could do-be in Ft Worth's rescue mission in the food line. During this time, she understood that there was a man whom she would meet who would change the city.

This is the story about how these pieces come together and the city starts on the course to be changed.

Thoughts:
When we use labels, we lose relationship.

Relationships are what round is into real people.

A catch and release program of friendship is not friendship but manipulation.



Evaluation:
The book title comes at the end where Denver is talking about how different he is than everybody else. He is even different from those who are homeless and definitely different from the Hall's. This is the root of Denver's concerns-how can people accept him if he is that much different than everybody else? His realization is that everybody is different, hence the title.

This true story is told in two voices: Ron Hall's and Denver Moore's. Most of the time, this is effective-because Moore's voice is that of a black, Southern, while Hall's is more white, sophisticated. The contrasts does work, but occasionally, there is less of a difference and you need to figure out who is talking.

What it does do is give a picture of the naivety of Hall and the distrust of Moore as the relationship is forming. Hall does not want to leave the comfort of what he has earned, the station of where is at. While Moore has figured out how to live homeless person and does not leave his life. Also his experience is that white people no matter how full of goodwill, are not to be trusted to be there for him.

There are lessons which the authors would like us to learn:
  • oppression is not a thing to be studied as in past history, but is practiced today in different forms, but with the same results
  • see beyond the outer shell of a person. Understand what is there inside.
  • we do not understand nor comprehend the workings of God. But that does not mean we are emotionless when we are hurt.
  • commitment is part of friendship.

 
Notes from my book group:

Questions:
  • How did the back and forth stories work for you?
  • After reading about the hamburger scam, are you looking at the freeway panhandler's any differently?
  • How believable is this story for you?
  • What did you learn by reading this book?
  • Who would you recommend this book to?
  • Do you agree that everybody is different? If so, how? How are we the same?
We had a good discussion on this book.


Good Quotes:
  • First Line: Until Miss Debbie, I'd never spoke to no white women before
  • Last Line: so in a way, we all is homeless--just working our way toward home.

References:

Sunday, April 7, 2013

Beowulf, translated by Lesslie Hall

Book: Beowulf
Translator: Leslie Hall
Edition: Gutenberg
Read: April 2013
325 pages
Rated: 3 out of 5

Synopsis:
Beowulf is a hero story and one of the oldest pieces of English literature. It talks about how Grendel a monster, related to Cain, was terrorizing the Danes. Beowulf comes from over the seas and grapples with Grendel and kills him. Grendel's mother seeks revenge and try's to kill Beowulf, but once again Beowulf defeats this monster's mom with his bare hands. Beowulf is lauded with honor and wealth, returning home a hero.

He then has the challenge of facing a dragon in his liar. Beowulf is deserted by his companions, except for one. The dragon gives Beowulf a mortal wound; but Beowulf's remaining companion slays the dragon. Beowulf's funeral pyre is bright and big enough to be a beacon for sailors.


Evaluation:
The story of Beowulf is well worth reading. There is much in the story to give one pause to consider. My evaluation of a three is more because of me than the work. I had a hard time with the translation and understanding terms not in common 21st century usage. So the flow of the story and understanding of it was interrupted. This meant the natural flow of the story was broken.

But the sense  sense of magnificence of Beowulf showed through. I am looking forward to reading this in a different translation, which a friend suggested: Seamus Heaney's version.

A good thing about Hall's version is he gives a short synopsis of the story. Then in the actual story, he has notes about what the section of the story is about. These were very helpful to me, and not too intrusive. 
 

Good Quotes:
  • First Line: “Lo! the Spear-Danes’ glory through splendid achievements
    The folk-kings’ former fame we have heard of,
    How princes displayed then their prowess-in-battle”
  • Last Line: “So lamented mourning the men of the Geats,
    Fond-loving vassals, the fall of their lord,
    An ideal king.
    Said he was kindest of kings under heaven,
    Gentlest of men, most winning of manner,
    Friendliest to folk-troops and fondest of honor.”

References:

Thursday, March 7, 2013

Every Last Cuckoo

Book: Every Last Cuckoo
Author: Kate Maloy
Edition: eBook from Barnes and Noble
Read: March 2013
219 pages
Rated: 3 out of 5

For those of you who have not read the book, and hate knowing what happens before reading it, there is some spoilage in this review. On the other hand, this is not a book which depends on surprise and ignorance.

Synopsis:
Charles dies. The first half of the book is where both Sarah and the reader reviews and learns of the relationship which Charles and Sarah has had during their marriage. The last half is Sarah learning to live without Charles.

Thoughts:

Maloy notes that the grumpy Charles emerged more often than he used to. I am wondering if Maloy is giving aging as a reason for grumpy old men?

there is more to growing old than she expected-what expectations do we have as we grow older? We know that our bodies will not support all which we used to be able to do. We know our minds will not be able to process as much. But is the expectation that all which we will do is sit in the corner and drool? So what expectations do I have on myself? That is the most important question. How does Maloy answer this? I think she does a good job. When Sarah losses her husband, she starts to take in people with needs. As she does this, her horizons grow. She feels like she is a new person. If Charles had not died, Sarah would not have done this. She would continue to live a content life.

Charles responds to Sarah's reminiscing with the line I prefer the present. (13) Does Charles value the present only? Or what makes the present possible from the past? Without our pasts, we have no depth to live our lives. I agree about living in the now, but we do need to understand our past and Where we are going to in order to live in the now. Is the present the only thing we have? What consideration do we have for the past/future?

Tess, Sarah and Charles son's girlfriend, notes that you should not have to know that you cannot perfectly protect the ones you love. (32) This is a good concept. You try to protect everyone, your kids, your parents, your wife. But you, your self are not invincible nor can you be everywhere. But when we see those whom we love get hurt, we feel the hurt, the anguish, fear, and anger. Also the guilt. It is good to be reminded we are neither infallible nor infinite. There is only one who is.

In another place, Sarah is remembering the feelings of losing her new-born. The phrase used is really poignant: giving birth to death. (41) How sad of a phrase. But that is the end to all birth. It is a mother's thought, but not until the hope for the child has first died.

The image which Maloy gives of Charles, I love: He never sits still enough for time to catch him. (63) Here is a man who is able to be busy, not with things to keep him busy-placeholder things, but with things which are of interest to him. His walks, the outdoors, his wife. He is a man who continues to expand, even as his body is retreating. He develops a relationship with his son, which was broken early on. There is something like a pillar about him. Even as he is dying, his wife sees in his face, all the men he had been for the past fifty years. A man who has changed, truly matured, not just grown old. Even as his last words to her, gives a senses of expansion-Oh Sarah, you would believe what I have just seen....

Death moved ceaselessly at the edge of her awareness, just out of reach, stalking her. A few sentences later, Sarah notes that she hopes she has dementia, since she would never see her own death coming. This is not a book about escaping death, but trying to live before death comes. Because of Sarah's age and her experience with loss, she knows about death. She also knows that it is a terrible fact of life. We will die. She just does not want to face a long, withering time of looking death in its face.

The camera gave her new eyes (98). It is amazing how getting behind a camera gives you new perspective. You see things for the first time, which has always been staring you in the face. The dew on a blade of grass-you notice the refraction of light; the texture of an old dried up leaf; or the smile on a child's face. Fresh eyes for a tired world.

Sarah is feeling guilty about how she cannot shake her grief for Charles. Sarah's son's girlfriend notes that Sarah spent her whole life with Charles and that is a lot to mourn. She then comes up with a practical help of going through Charles stuff with Sarah. Two thought occurs to me: First, a good friend will find a way to be of use to a person in mourning-meals, time together, cleaning up. Secondly, is there a relationship between the length of time you are with someone and how long you mourn them? I suspect it may have more to do with how many holes the person has left in your life and how many unresolved issues you may have had.

Maloy brings in the Tess character, who is a Quaker and her son's girl from. She and a Jewish boarder have a dialogue about war. The Jewish boarder's thoughts are that wars are never about ideas-more about greed and hate. But Tess says that Quakers have evaluated wars, trying to assess the risks associated with the war. While Maloy does not state this, you understand the risk to be about the good or evil coming out of a war. But how can you do that? Very few wars are that cut and dried. Especially if you are in the middle of the war. But that is where we need to make our decisions-in real life. Maloy does not give us guidance on this. But she does understand the hardness of real time decisions. (162)

Maloy describes the lack of drive after the loss of a spouse. She talks about how all which Sarah wants to do is wander in the woods, taking pictures, minding the garden-things which Charles loved. But some things, like the linens folded crisply, which both of them liked, now recede I importance. This brings to mind that we live together and form patterns of behavior learned from each other. What will stand alone?

I do not understand what Maloy means when she says, You still believe you can solve the mystery of your mind, with your mind.... You wish to comprehend instead of apprehend. (172) What does this mean? Sounds sort of meaningless to me. Maloy goes on to say, the trick is to do it on purpose, then to guide the mind without pushing or tugging on it. (172). How is this done?

She was just a thing, like a sound or a scent. (180). Just a thing? We should never be that, except when we are before God. And even then, a thing is not what we are. We are creatures made in His image, maybe very small when compared with Him, but the object of His love which enlarges us when compared to what s around us. Of course, Maloy is probably only trying to say, that Sarah is not noticeable in the scenery which she is surrounded by.

As Sarah is growing more feeble, Maloy says that Sarah's life is all story, (181) parts of it incomplete, parts of it fulfilled. That is so true. Our lives are stories. We should live on in our friends and families lives as stories which they like to tell, enlarge and glorify. As they enjoy us now, they should enjoy us later. Also we should enjoy those who came before us.

Now for the title of the book. Some, and not even most species, cuckoo birds will try to hide their eggs with others, so that other bird will hatch and nurture them. Sort of leads up to why some of those birds grow up with mixed up identities. This is what happens with Sarah, she starts to have others, beginning with her granddaughter, Lottie, live with her. Lottie brings in some friends who are having parent troubles. Then others hear about this and asks her to temporarily house people in need. Soon the house bulging with these people. Sarah, while not forgetting or stopping to miss Charles, she finds herself being able to fill some of the void left in her life. She finds others will do the things, like housework, for her while she can make the time to be walk and wonder.



Evaluation:
This book read like a Jan Karon novel, except without the Christian thought behind it. The book lets the reader understand that us old people do have a life which we value and which can be found fulfilling. Life does not stop at 60.

Maloy says that the book  is for her Mom and Grandmother, as well as her aunt whom she thinks Sarah resembles. As I am reading the book, I gathered that Maloy also hopes she can turn into the woman which Sarah develops into after her husband's death. There is a certain wistfulness in her writing in places which suggests Maloy is working out who she wants to become.

The good part of this book is the ability to explore loss and feelings, to examine how do we age and what are our needs. The unrealistic in this book is how Sarah grows stronger as she moves away from the loss of her husband, and as she grows older. In her own words, to write searching, not sizzling books.

When Sarah climbed up some rocks with Charles, she notes that such places are good for the soul. To be able to see ridge, beyond ridge, beyond ridge, gives a sense of standing on the verge of infinity. From a high Sierra mountain, you can see the curvature of the earth. Those times give me a sense of being able to look beyond horizons. This gives the perspective to understand how small I am, but also how big God is.

 
 
Notes from my book group:

My group generally did not lik the book. Some thought it was not that well written. Others did not like the lack of morality in it, as well as the use of sex, pot and swearing. They also thought it was predictable and it sounded like Maloy had a list of liberal issues she wanted to address, which she does address. But in places, it read like checking off boxes rather than exploring parts of this in depth. She does not differ any from a standard eastern liberal. Also there was a thought of is she really representing Quaker thought? From the Quakers we knew, this did not seem to be the case.
  1. What expectations of ourselves, of life, do we have as we grow older (old)?        Living in the moment causes you to be more in touch with humanism, than the eternal which Christianity presents.
  2.  Charles responds to Sarah's reminiscing with the line I prefer the present. (13) Is the present the only thing we have? What consideration do we have for the past/future?
  3. How does anger and fear influence our characters? What place does joy and happiness play in this book? 
  4. Does the camera give Sarah fresh perspective on her surroundings or is that a metaphor for something larger in her life?
  5. Death plays the form in many part in this book. For example, Charles' death, the death of Sarah's son Andrew and Tess' husband Ian.
    1. In last month's book, Book Thief, Zusak has death being the narrator. How does Maloy treat death in this book?
    2. How did the phrase: giving birth to death affect you?
    3. How would you have written about death-like Zusak or Maloy or something different?
  6. Tess, even though a little more than a stranger, assisted Sarah in her grief. How can we help people mourn and pass through their grief?     It was brought up in the Congo, there is a phrase, "sitting for death." This is where people will come and just sit with you. Listening is good.
  7. There is a discussion about war-never being about principles, but about geed and hate.  How would you respond to this? Tess responds that Quakers assess risk about war. Can this be done? How? The response is that we have a hard time making that assessment in real time.
  8. Maloy's web site says that she is a practicing Quaker. How does this background get infused in the book?
  9. You still believe you can solve the mystery of your mind, with your mind.... You wish to comprehend instead of apprehend. Explain what this means.
  10. Respond to Maloy's statement on pg 180: She was just a thing, like a sound or a scent
  11. A person's life is a story. How so? What difference does it make if life is a story?
  12. What do you speculate that Charles saw at the last:  Oh Sarah, you would believe what I have just seen....  How did it affect Sarah? What do you think Maloy was thinking? Just a good literary device or does she have something in mind?



New Words:
  • evanescence (41):  the event of fading and gradually vanishing from sight; "the evanescence of the morning mist".
  •  Esse (47): Essential nature or essence
  •  Catamount (137): A medium-sized or large wild cat, esp. a cougar.

Good Quotes:
  • First Line: on fear alone, Sarah Lucas follows her dog Sylvie down a long meadow and onto a disintegrating ski trail in the woods.
  • Last Line: There wasn't a thing she could do about loss.
  •  She had lived many thousands of days, so it was not surprising that scenes from an hour here or a moment there should surface at random. (8)
  •  Sarah thought such perspectives were good for the soul. (58)
  •  He never sits still enough for time to catch him. (63)
  •  The camera gave her new eyes. (98)
  •  His life was his art, and all of you, alone and in connection with each other and with us, were his masterpieces. (101)
  •  Some people just will not give up their hate. (155)
  •  War was never about ideas, it was always about hatred and greed. (155)
  •  To hate in the name of love, to kill in the name of safety. There will be no peace anywhere until we unlearn such stupidity. (163)
  •  Love always brings loss. Nevertheless, love is where she would put her energies, because that was where her powers lay. (219)


References: