Monday, May 4, 2026

Project Hail Mary

 

Book: Project Hail Mary

Basic Information : Synopsis : Characters : Expectations : Thoughts : Evaluation : Book Group : New Words : Good Quotes : References

Basic Information:

Author:  Andy Weir

Edition: epub on Libby from Fresno Public Library

Publisher: Ballantine Books 

ISBN:     9780593135204 (ISBN10: 0593135202)

Start Date:  April 25, 2026

Read Date: May 4, 2026

476 pages

Genre:  Fiction, Science

Language Warning:  Low

Rated Overall: 4½   out of 5


Fiction-Tells a good story: 5 out of 5

Fiction-Character development: 5 out of 5



Synopsis (Caution: Spoiler Alert-Jump to Thoughts):

Earth is being threatened, not by some hideous monster from outer space, coming to Earth blasting guns at us. Rather this threat is from little organisms which are absorbing the energy of the sun. How? They are going back and forth between the sun and Venus to mate, producing more of these organisms. It is noticed that other stars seem to be dimming, except for one. Why is that one not dining, even though there are these organisms there?


All nations on earth realizing that this would be a disaster for all humans, band together to figure out what the problem is and how to solve it. A Dutch woman is given all power to save the world. A discredited doctor is summoned to identify what is going on and to remedy the situation. He finds out what is going on.


The solution is in another galaxy several light years away. This is a suicide trip as there will not be enough energy to return them, they can only return a small craft with what they found. Two astronauts and a scientist are brought together to go. But the scientists dies before take off.


There is only one scientist who is uniquely qualified and fit to do the job-the discredited scientist. He is kidnapped and put on the space ship. When he wakes up the other two are dead and only he is alive.


When the spaceship gets to the galaxy, another ship from another galaxy also arrives. The occupant is a giant spider-like creature. They coordinate what they know. Much of the book is about the meeting and subsequent cooperation. Of course there are several issues which pop up and are solved.


They depart with the answer on how to save their worlds. But the solution to the sun’s depletion of energy ends up creating problems for the scientist which jeopardizes his return. He sends the information off in the information craft and works on trying to salvage his return. In the meantime, the scientist realizes his spider-like friend also has the same issue. The scientist, knowing he will be lost, rescues his friend.



Cast of Characters:
  • Ryland Grace -disgraced scientist who saves Earth
  • Rocky-Spider like alien
  • Eva Stratt-Appoint leader with all powers the world can give to save Earth
  • Commander Yáo-Captain of the spacecraft, does not wake up from coma
  • Ilyukhina - Second officer of space craft. Does not wake up from coma
  • Dimitri Komorov -Scientist who will be on the spacecraft, but dies on Earth due to an explosion
  • Dr Xi-Chinese scientist
  • Dr. Lokken -
  • Dr. Robert Redell -
  • Dr. François Leclerc -
  • Dr. Lamai -
  • Martin DuBois -Scientist who will be on the spacecraft, but dies on Earth due to an explosion
  • Annie Shapiro - BackupScientist who will be on the spacecraft, but dies on Earth due to an explosion
  • Steve Hatch-
  • Dr. Irina Petrova -
  • Marissa -



Expectations:
  • Recommendation: Rachel and others
  • When: January 2026
  • Date Became Aware of Book: ???
  • Why do I want to read this book: Andy Weir is a good writer.
  • What do I think I will get out of it? A good read with lots of science behind it.

Thoughts:


Chapter 1

Ryland Grace comes out of suspended animation and slowly remembers things like his name and what brought him here. The two people sent with him are dead. He is wobbly and trying to figure out who he is. Before he knows who he is, it is a process of figuring out what he is good at and deciding he has a good physics background. He realizes that he is no longer on earth as the gravity is different.


This gives you an idea of how the book goes. Grace looks for clues to his identity and e slowly realizes who he is as he regains memories. That is until an alien comes along where it seems like Grace becomes fully cognizant of who he is.



Chapter 2

Petrova line-central to the book as it deals with why the sun is dimming. The computation is 1% over the next five years; 5% over the next 20. Ice Age time. The Petrova line is made up of life about 10 microns across.


He realizes he is on a spaceship and that the other two crew members are dead. He is the only one alive. He also realizes that he was a teacher.



Chapter 3

Grace is remembering being back teaching junior high schoolers science. They have been processing the news about how the sun is dimming and there is general pessimism. But Grace thinks what ’s the point of even having a world if you’re not going to pass it on to the next generation?


Jacob’s ladder


Talks about cultivating his reputation as a “cool” teacher-one who cares about the kids.


I can’t fault someone for loving their kids, and God knows we could do with more parents being engaged in their kids’ educations, but there’s a limit.


Eva Stratt, who is in charge of finding out what is happening to the Petrova line and how to solve the sun problem. Grace wrote a paper on how a different form of life may not need hydrogen and liquid water. This has caught her attention as a possible key link in the problem she is solving. He is kidnapped by the FBI as he will be the one trying to identify if the make up of the Petrova line is alive. He is given a well stocked biology lab in some mysterious building.


Through this exercise in memory, he knows his name, Dr. Ryland Grace. He knows he is on a spaceship called the Hail Mary. But he does not know where he is going.


He is back to the lab memory and being the first one to look at the little dots which may be life. Stratt questions him after six hours on what he found. They probably are life and give off a lot of light which is how they move around. He called them Astrophage-something which lives off of stars.


Back on the spaceship he realizes that things are off, the sun he is observing is not our own, but a different solar system.



Chapter 4

Grace figures out that he is in a different solar system and remembers himself being in a lab where he discovers what Astrophage is. He also discovers how simple they are. On the spaceship, he finds out he is on a one way trip to whatever solar system it is. There are four “beetles” which will take information back to earth.



Chapter 5

Grace talks about working with trying to figure out what the Astrophage were like. He found they went for carbon dioxide. Also he found that he had created another Astrophage besides the three he had. He discovered their life cycle. Go to the sun to get energy, go to Venus with its carbon-dioxide and bread. Then back to the sun.Get energy, get resources, and make copies. It’s the same thing all life on Earth does.


Apparently his discovery triggered something as he is whisked away immediately, including landing on a Chinese aircraft carrier. There is a gathering of 15 people, mostly scientists listening while he describes what he did. He is introduced to Project Hail Mary. Our star, the sun, is not the only star dimming. Looks like the center of activity is a star called Tau Ceti. While being the center of activity, it has not dimmed like stars around it.



Chapter 6

Grace is working through what he is doing on the spaceship. Also what can the spaceship do?


At the end of the chapter, an alien ship has come alongside the Hail Mary.



Chapter 7

Rudimentary communications with the alien ship. It sends over a cylinder and Grace goes outside in a Russian suit. The cylinder contains ammonia gas and is hot.



Chapter 8

The cylinder is made out of Xenon-he will call it xenonite. This comes into play later on in the story. The aliens have communicated they are from a star based area called 40 Eridani. The ship wants to connect with the Hail Mary.



Chapter 9

Connecting the two ships for first contact.



Chapter 10

He meets/sees the alien on the other side of the xenonite wall. A brown clawed crab/spider-like being, which he initially mistakes for a rock. He calls this being Rocky.



Chapter 11

Learning to communicate.



Chapter 12

Grace and Rocky are learning each other’s language. Rochy’s is musical, like a whale song. Rocky wants Grace to watch him sleep. Grace asks why can’t the rest of his crew watch him sleep? Rocky says that there were 23 of him on the original crew. Now there is only him. Just like Grace. They bond over that.



Chapter 14

The chapter starts off with Who would have thought that saving the world could be so boring?


In some ways, this is a book about what happens to our environment when things change which we take for granted. In this case, the sun does not put out as much energy. Weir also writes pretty engagingly as well, so even without the underlying message, it still would be a good read.


Grace goes into why Rocky’s crewmates did die and he did not. He was shielded from radiation and they were not. Weir actually goes into why the Hail Mary had shielding in a previous chapter.


Sometimes you have to do what you do not want to do for your or your species survival.


Rocky makes a space suit which he can be in the Hail Mary.



Chapter 15

Rocky brings stuff into the Hail Mary. From there, they will work on the Atrophage problem.



Chapter 17

Grace notes how eerie it is to have Rocky looking at him when he wakes up. It is part of Rocky’s culture to make sure his kind wake up from sleep. We haven’t run into anything where our cultures clash…yet.


Discrepancy is science. You think about discrepancy. Make science.


Rocky and Grace have gone to a planet where the Astrophage goes to and from the sun. But they discover that there is not an equilibrium. Instead there are other kinds of life. This other kind of life is a predator of the Astrophage which Grace calls the taumoeba.



Chapter 18

Weir has one of the characters saying that He [God] was pretty awesome to to make relativity a thing, … The faster you go, the less time you experience. It’s like He’s inviting us to explore the universe… Interesting line of thought.



Chapter 19

They are going to sample the area of the planet where they think the predator of the Astrophage is. They have made a six mile chain so the ship does not need to go down into the atmosphere. They get the sample.


But in doing so, the ship had started to melt. Rocky saves Grace, but has exposed himself to the wrong atmosphere and is dying.



Chapter 20

Grace works on saving Rocky.


He has an interesting thought as he has taken many chances in doing this. Anything which I do beyond this moment is a gift from the universe to me. I am pretty sure Weir thinks this is a throw away thought. But it does indicate that there is a concept that the universe does have a personality, being able to give reprieve and gifts.


Grace works through some basic biology of Rocky. He realizes that he is not able to operate or anything like that. But he figures out how to clean some of the soot off of him.



Chapter 21

Rocky awakes. Grace finds out that the soot he cleaned out of Rocky was like a scab which helped him heal.


I’m smart enough now to know I’m stupid. That is something which we all can learn. Being on painkilling drugs is something he called enhanced stupidity. I like that term.


Scene switches back to Russia a few days before launch. The primary scientist and his backup died in an explosion and now someone needs to be selected to take their place.


They have found a predator which eats Atrophage and calls it Taumoeba. It is quite aggressive.



Chapter 22

The Taumoeba has gotten into the fuel lines where the fuel is Astrophage. The ship stops functioning. They figure out how to get the ship functioning and moving back to Rocky’s ship using the pods which were going to be sent back to Earth.



Chapter 23

Back in Russia, after the scientists are blown up, Grace is the most obvious choice to replace. He is reluctant. Stratt kidnaps him and puts him into a coma for the launch.



Chapter 24

Grace realizes he is a coward.


They find their way back to Rocky’s ship.



Chapter 25

All are ready to leave each other. Rocky has his Taumoeba and Grace has his. And they leave.



Chapter 26

Weir gives a summary of what will happen if climate change is not checked. But he does it in the form of a speech by Stratt.


They are on their way home.



Chapter 27

Occasionally Weir throws in a sentence which should make the reader smile. Such as thanking the primary scientist for Grace’s life because of the scientist’s preferred method of suicide. The Taumoeba have escaped, but Grace catches it early and kills them with excessive amounts of nitrogen.



Chapter 28

The new and enhanced Taumoeba can get its way through the Rocky made material, but not steel or plastic. It hits Grace that Rocky is in trouble.



Chapter 29

Grace has a classic dilemma: go back to earth and save the world and himself or save Rocky and his planet-sending little rescue ships with information back to Earth and saving it, but dying in the process. He makes his decision: to save Rocky and his planet. A few chapters ago, he realizes he is a coward. But this is a heroic decision.


Grace finds Rocky’s ship and manages to attract his attention. Rocky comes over and may have figured out how to save Grace.



Chapter 30

Grace has lived on Erid for 16 earth years now. They have built him a dome which he can live in. The gravity is much more than earth, and has a debilitating effect. The Eridian would have been glad to repair the Hail Mary and send him back. Rocky does give him the news that Earth’s sun has been restored, so Grace knows the mission was successful. But he is not ready to go back. He is teaching some young Eridrians.



Evaluation:

This is my third Andy Weir book-The Martian and Artemis being the other two. If he keeps writing them like this, I will keep reading them


By now I think everybody knows the basic story lines of Project Hail Mary! Discredited scientist is sent into space, befriends an alien and saves not only his own world but alien friends world. What is interesting to me is what happens between all of that-otherwise it is a normal book which is worth about an hour of ones time.


Weir has a way of making complex scientific knowledge both understandable and entertaining. He weaves it into the plot-not hiding it, rather using it to further the plot. Weir is one of those rae authors who educates you as well as entertains you.


 
Notes from my book group:



what ’s the point of even having a world if you’re not going to pass it on to the next generation? Eventually our evolutionary chain will give out. Is there a point in educating at all?


As you read the book, did you come to a better understanding of how science is done? Also when the questions or answers being asked are wrong?


What did you make of these sentences: Discrepancy is science. You think about discrepancy. Make science. ?


When you come across a person who speaks a different language, how do you establish communications? What if you did not have a dictionary which cross-referenced words?


Is this book about climate change?


Do you think this book accurately portrayed what happens when there is a small amount of difference in the environment?


Stratt forces Grace to go on a suicide mission. What are the ethics behind this? Is this similar to Spock saying the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few?


One thing which Grace discovers is that even though he behaved cowardly when on earth, he has performed heroically when in space. Was this something part of Grace already? Or was the difference in location? Or something else triggered this change of character? What does this say about ourselves?


Weir has several trains of religious thought, ranging from He [God] was pretty awesome to to make relativity a thing, … It’s like He’s inviting us to explore the universe to Anything which I do beyond this moment is a gift from the universe to me. Does Wier have a consistent religious view presented in this book?


What does the author want us to feel when we read this book?


How do you want your life to change because you read this book?


Many of these questions are either from or adapted from LitLovers.

Why the title of Project Hail Mary?

Does this story work as science-fiction?

Did the ending seem fitting? Satisfying? Predictable?

Which character was the most convincing? Least?

Which character did you identify with?

Which one did you dislike?

Every story has a world view. Were you able to identify this story’s world view? What was it? How did it affect the story?

In what context was religion talked about in this book?

Why do you think the author wrote this book?

What would you ask the author if you had a chance?

What “takeaways” did you have from this book?

What central ideas does the author present?

How did this book affect your view of the world?

Of how God is viewed?

What questions did you ask yourself after reading this book?

Talk about specific passages that struck you as significant—or interesting, profound, amusing, illuminating, disturbing, sad...?

What was memorable?

Reading Groups General Fiction Guide



New Words:
  • Carapace: a dorsal (upper) section of the exoskeleton or shell in a number of animal groups, including arthropods, such as crustaceans and arachnids.
  • Panspermia: the hypothesis that life exists throughout the universe, distributed by cosmic dust, meteoroids, asteroids, comets, and planetoids, as well as by spacecraft carrying unintended contamination by microorganisms, known as directed panspermia. The theory argues that life did not originate on Earth, but instead evolved somewhere else and seeded life as we know it.
  • Oberth effect: a maneuver in which a spacecraft falls into a gravitational well and then uses its engines to further accelerate as it is falling, thereby achieving additional speed.



Good Quotes:
  • First Line: What’s two plus two
  • Last Line: Twelve kids raise their claws.
  • what ’s the point of even having a world if you’re not going to pass it on to the next generation? Chp 3
  • Discrepancy is science. You think about discrepancy. Make science. Chp 15
  • I’m smart enough now to know I’m stupid. Chp 21

Wednesday, February 11, 2026

Heartwwood

 


Book: Heartwwood

Basic Information : Synopsis : Characters : Expectations : Thoughts : Evaluation : Book Group : New Words : Book References : Good Quotes :  References

Basic Information:

Author: Amity Gaige

Edition: epub on Libby from the Fresno Public Library

Publisher: Simon & Schuster

ISBN: 9781668063606 (ISBN10: 1668063603)

Start Date:  February 5, 2026

Read Date: February 11, 2026 

309 pages

Genre:  Fiction, Outdoor,OSHER

Language Warning:  Low

Rated Overall: 3  out of 5


Fiction-Tells a good story:4 out of 5

Fiction-Character development: 3½  out of 5



Synopsis (Caution: Spoiler Alert-Jump to Thoughts):

There are several threads to this story. The main one is finding a lost hiker in Maine who was on the Appalachian Trail. It goes through how the search is done. The story also involves being close to a Naval survival school as well as a young man with mental issues. The hiker is found.


A sub-story is a 76 year old lady in an assisted living facility who likes to forage, but is a loner. She and her daughter are estranged. The two slowly work on getting together.


Then there is the story of the survival of the hiker.




Cast of Characters:
  • See Book Companion for a complete list of characters
  • Valerie Gillis-aka Sparrow, lost hiker. 42 years old, Caucasian, nurse
  • Ruben Serrano-aka Santo, Sparrow’s hiking partner until he left the trail
  • Beverly Miller-Lieutenant warden, in command of the search
  • Rob Cross-Beverly’s second in command
  • Tanya Duning-investigator for the search
  • Cody Ouellette-warden
  • Gregory Bouras-Valerie’s husband
  • Lena Kugharski-76 year old woman in rest home. Divorced, having one child, Christine who is estranged from her. Became a cytologist.
  • Daniel Means-username, Terrible Silence
  • Warren Esterman-friend of Lena, retired lawyer
  • Wayne Gillis-Valerie’s father
  • Janet Gillis-Valerie’s mother
  • Christine-Lena’s long lost daughter.

Expectations:
  • Recommendation: OSHER Book Club
  • When: November 2025
  • Why do I want to read this book: OSHER Book Club
  • What do I think I will get out of it? Entertaining story of a lost hiker

Thoughts:


OSHER Book Club blurb: Heartwood by Amnity Gaige

In the heart of the Maine woods, an experienced Appalachian Trail hiker goes missing. She is forty-two-year-old Valerie Gillis, who has vanished 200 miles from her final destination. Alone in the wilderness, Valerie pours her thoughts into fractured, poetic letters to her mother as she battles the elements and struggles to keep hoping. At the heart of the investigation is Beverly, the determined Maine State Game Warden tasked with finding Valerie, who leads the search on the ground. Meanwhile, Lena, a seventy- six-year-old birdwatcher in a Connecticut retirement community, becomes an unexpected armchair detective. Roving between these compelling narratives, a puzzle emerges, intensifying the frantic search, as Valerie’s disappearance may not be accidental. The mystery inspires larger questions about the many ways in which we get lost, and how we are found.

Comments made during our OSHER Book CLub:

  • Valerie had no business out there without having more experience

    • It was interesting to me that it was brought up that was this attitude because she was a woman? To me, not because I would say the same thing if a male had the same skill level she had. 

  • Racism on trail-this was concern about Santo

  • Listening to the book on audio was better than reading it. The audio had different voices  and actors for each charter.

  • It seemed like many characters had a drive to accomplish something

  • Good descriptions

  • Where did she have the paper to write?

  • One person tried to make a case a person has a right to go into the wild without being prepared.

    • I do not think so because you are also putting rescuers in danger.

  • Gaige tried to add mystery to a straightforward story

  • There seemed to be a time disconnect

  • Nancy Guthrie-current lost person

  • Many mother-daughter relationships in the book

  • Gets on trail and which is uncomfortable to her while Valerie was tried to comfort others. Was she able to feel comfortable herself?

 


Gaige seems to like very technical words. Most of the time the more general word would do. I am thinking she may have a new thesaurus and wants to show she can use it.


Many chapters are divided into two or three parts. The first is the thoughts of the person named in the chapter heading. Second is some item which the Wardens have done or are examining, and third is writings from Sparrow. Also there is more background, usually given by Santo, Sparrow’s hiking partner. Then last is usually and entry from Sparrow’s journal.


Valerie gives herself a trail name of Sparrow. Santa also names himself. A trail name is meant to be some part of your recognized identity by other hikers. Out West here, it seems like that is mostly frowned on-but looking at a site, they advocate giving yourself a name while another site noted that is frowned on. There was a survey of AT hikes, 223 of them, something like 80% of them were gifted the name. 20% gave themselves their name. That surprises me. 

 

I have charted out the area which most of this book takes place on Google Earth. The kmz file can be found by clicking on this link.

 




Epigraph

Valerie has an entry about who she is and why she is called Sparrow.


In this chapter, Valerie calls her mother her heartwood, someone who is the core of who she is.



1. Lt. Bev

Any woodsman who says he’s never been lost in the woods is a liar. Then again Daniel Boone has been reported to say that “I’ve never been lost, but I was mighty turned around for three days once.” And I have a tendency to say that I have never been lost in the mountains of the Sierra. Now sometimes in a city I have been turned around. Also I have the tendency to be turned around right at the start of a walk. I have been reported lost once, but I knew where I was, my hiking partner just walked right by me.


I do like this statement: Up here, we tend to think of being lost as something you can be good at. I like to think that I am pretty good at wandering. Or as Tolkien said, “Not all who wander are lost.”


loss of mental control is more dangerous than the lack of food or water. This is what I have read. Keeping your cool and being optimistic will increase your chances of survival.


This is where Gaige brings in the lost hiker of the AT, Valerie Gillis. She started in Harpers Ferry, WV on April 21st and has been slowly hiking for three months.


Lt Bev explains how easy it is to get lost in the woods of Maine.


Then she explains what it is to search for a lost hiker. It is a guess on the most probable location. They have a starting place: July 25th starting at Poplar Ridge shelter. May have been seen at Spaulding Mountain shelter.


Sparrows’s thoughts.

hiking the Appalachian Trail isn’t a reasonable thing to do. She notes you do not hike that long to find beauty-you are looking for something else. She describes the pains and suffering of a thru hiker. It is not if you will feel bad, it is how bad, how critical and how much you can stand. the act of walking while carrying the weight of my pack had wrung all the sadness out of me, the sadness for myself and for the world.


Either a long distance hike will break you or change you. In Sparrow’s case, The trail transformed me


Talks about Santos how he is a chubby boy from the Bronx. And his relationship with Sparrow.



2. Lt. Bev

References Maine code: Title 12, section 10105. What Gaige omitted was that it is paragraph 4 which is important for Search and Rescue: Whenever the commissioner receives notification that any person has gone into the woodlands or onto the inland waters of the State on a hunting, fishing or other trip and has become lost, stranded or drowned, the commissioner shall exercise the authority to take reasonable steps to ensure the safe and timely recovery of that person, … There are several subparts to this as well.


Gaige references some stats. In the Maine 2024 Search and Rescue Report, there is some interesting information:

The “Hasty Search” is the most effective and most utilized tactic that results in a find. This tactic involves quick searching in high probability areas that will most likely find the lost person. Hasty searches accounted for120 finds during FY24. “Self-found” is a category that generally occurs very quickly after a person is reported lost or missing. The lost person or persons generally figure out where they are and report back to the caller before we arrive on scene.


Last Seen (PLS) that a dispatcher or warden can obtain at the time to where the subject was located. As has always been the trend, the majority (75%) of lost people are found within a quarter of a mile from the PLS. 87% of lost people are found within 1 mile from the PLS. Searching a mile on land or water takes a considerable number of resources, time and effort to do effectively.


When you exclude the 26 individuals who were found deceased that were outside of our “control” we located 98.6% of missing persons alive. The outside control is either water related-drowning-or suicide.


In the Maine 2020 Search and Rescue Report, the time and probability of rescue is the same as what Gaige reports:


Our data shows that within 12 hours, 92% of the people are located. Within 24 hours, 97% of people are located. These statistics have been the same for over a decade since we started keeping this statistic. Multi-day search operations are not a common occurrence.


Says they were assembling at Sugarloaf Mountain Hotel which is on the other side of the mountain. But there is a ski lift and a good trail to the Spaulding shelter. Talks about the process of putting together teams of searchers.


Talks about Valerie’s husband and meeting him.


crime is rare on the trail. I think this is generally true. But it is not rare for a single female to be harassed by a male in the backcountry.


All sorts of people with false leads come out the woodwork-some might-haves, some just wanted to get involved, some are just loppy.



3. Lt. Bev

More description of how searchers search-in a line, side-by-side, closely spaced. At the end of the sector, they swing around and go to the next area-the searching is only as wide of the line as they are in. Consequently in deep forest or brush or rocks, searchers can get really battered and scratched. Slow, labor intensive process.


Bev wonders at night what Valerie is looking at. Bev also relives her childhood.


She goes through her childhood and the bullying she received as a 6’ female in school. She was out there in the woods looking for a sign, you see. I wanted to be called to something. Interesting that Gaige presents the concept of calling. It raises the question of who would be calling Beverly and to what purpose? She roused a deer once and realized that was what she was meant to do. Breath of a doe. That was my call.


She is driven to find lost people; driven to find Valerie.


Sparrow is not really an outdoors person. She has a hard time lighting a fire-which I have also had that experience when everything is wet. She has also lost a boot. She both laughs and cries when I cannot believe what is happening to me


She is starting to starve. How long can a person go without food? She has been hiking for months. Generally there is a calorie deficiency when thru-hiking. Such as when we hiked the JMT, we backed around 2500 calories per day, but expended between 3500 and 4500 calories in a day's activity. When Valerie was at this point, she probably did not have too much excess fat and would have started consuming muscle if she was moving.


She has enough sense to stay in one place. Then Gaige gives us the hook to continue reading. I don’t know which scares me more—being found by him, or being found by no one.



4. Lena

Lena is a loner in a retirement community. She reads and thinks that without books, there was nothing but time. Learning came fast for her. She was considered special as in an odd ball as she did not follow the crowd. She is Polish and 76, and cannot move around easily without her wheelchair. She loves to forage behind the community with her friend Warren.


Lena is occasionally beset by a nauseating transition between the page and the world, as if a decision has been handed down in these twilight years of her life: world trumps book.


no matter how much you study life, it studies you back.


Through a foraging Reddit subsite, she became friends with TerribleSilence. But not really does she know anything about this person except that TerribleSilence is a he and an expert in the field of foraging. He also lives in Bethel, Maine.


He is the one who notes the missing hiker to Lena and rouses her interest. Lena wonders if it is her long lost daughter, Christine.


Lena talks with Warren and says her fears. She cannot bear the suggestion that her mind is unsafe.



5. Lt. Bev

Start of massive search, including dog teams and volunteer searchers. Like the Amish raise their barns, Mainers search for each other in the woods. It’s what we do.


They have a tip line going. Only about 2 percent of tip line calls are useful. Ruben Serrano calls, aka Santo, who was Valerie’s hiking partner until he needed to go back to New York. She sends Cody to interview him. They form a relationship.


Bev has put her personal life on hold during this crucial part of the search.


Valerie does not have much in the way of wilderness skills or experience, except this trail. The husband says that Valerie does not love him anymore-it is something she realized out on the trail. But he still loves her and supports her time on the trail.


No real sign of Valerie at the end of the day. Her mother and dad show up, very optimistically.



6. Lena

A picture is published and Lena realizes that Valerie is not her daughter, but Lena feels a wrenching intimacy with her regardless. The picture is a clue to what happened to the hiker. Gaige publishes a bogus website for AT hikers: 2000milers.net. There are real ones and real Facebook groups for each long trail and many shorter ones.


Switches to Valerie’s journal and how she does not have much food-about a thousand calories remaining. She eventually eats grubs. Also her foot has been cut. She says that no one hikes two thousand miles because they’re happy. I do not know about the 2000 miles, but I have met many folks who have hiked 200 miles and are content with themselves and glad that they are doing it. I for one. So why does Gaige say this?


Everybody’s got a reason to hike the trail. I would agree with that. Some people look at a long trail as something which they need to do, like a marathon. Others do it to get away from people. Some because they enjoy being around someone else. And other are trying to understand themselves better.


Valerie is hiking the AT because being a nurse during the pandemic, she was overwhelmed. She needed to go back and discover herself. She needed to recover from the stress. I wanted someone to acknowledge my moral injury.


She sees a search plane, but it does not see her.


Santo is being interviewed. He says that Valerie had become content on the trail, with the people on the trail. He notes that You have to walk it to understand it.



7. Lt. Bev

Day four of the search. Press conference. Wayne and Janet seem to accept and even love him [Gregroy], which, for the moment, is good enough for me. The family trusts Bev.



9. Lena

Talks about Lena and her husband’s relationship: They were both so stupid when they were mad. This is probably true anytime a person is mad.


To many people she appeared lonely. Gaige points out that A reader is never lonely. … she didn’t like people, so how could she be lonely for them?


Talks about how she started communicating with TerribleSilence.


TerribleSilence comes back and thinks that Valerie has been captured by SERE. There is a Naval version of this in Maine at Rangeley. The main part is at least 10 miles away from where Valerie was last seen. But there is a section of six miles where the AT bisects SERE. This is where Valerie stayed the night and was moving towards Spaulding Mountain.


As a note: there is a Marine SERE base on the other side of Sonora Pass called Mountain Warfare Training Center . These bases are not really super-secrative, not saying you can just walk in. There are others in California, usually around existing military bases.


When I read this part of the book, I wondered, are we going to wander down a conspiracy rabbit hole? There should have been a clue when TerribleSilence started spouting crazy stuff such as getting into a fistfight with people from SERE and coming out of it with information.



10. Lt. Bev

Carrabassett mountains-not really a named set of mountains, at least not on GNIS. Maybe a local designation.


She is getting frustrated by not finding Valerie and wants to go out into the field to actually see what is going on.


Penobscot-an Indigenous people in North America from the Northeastern Woodlands region.


Talks about Regina and her dog Badger. Talks about scents. I am thinking of the book The Last Season where the dog had a scent of Randy Morgensten and then it disappeared. Regina is almost a friend of Bev.


SERE people show up saying they have been assigned to look for the lost hiker. They said they are half a mile out of their area. Wonder where they were searching or what lead them there?


Valerie’s journal:

Describes how she left the trail. A 20 year old kid said they had to get out of there. She followed him off the trail and then through brush. Then quickly got out of sight of the trail. If I had turned around, I wouldn’t be writing this letter. The guy seemed to know where he was going. When they came to a cliff, he threw her pack of it. She wanted to leave, but he would not let her. She had no idea where they were.


He tells her why he cannot let her go. There is a secret installation where they are working twenty-four-hour darkness. He calls it The Night Army. I wonder if she borrowed this from The Lord of the Rings? Or maybe a version of The Game of Thrones.


There is an interesting statement of never try to call the bluff of a madman.


She tries to run away. He catches her-her thought, what a waste of energy.


After reading the book, I plotted out a few things and wondered, how did the man go past the SERE facility? There is a narrow corridor which the trail goes through SERE for about 6 miles. I cannot believe they passed through the actual SERE without being detected. Maybe him, but I do not think she would be quiet.



11. Lt. Bev

Bev finds Valerie’s mother standing in front of a store handing out flyers about her daughter. Bev joins here. Mothers like her will light the last night on earth.


Describes Bev’s family.


Gaige has a line about stars: Those stars, those stars that don’t care. This reminds me of a book by Daniel James Brown called The Indifferent Stars Above. It is about the Donner Party. I wonder if that is what caused Gaige to write that sentence.


Bev's mom did not understand what drove her. When she got the position of game warden, her mother said There must be a reason there’s no other women in that line of work.


But what drives Bev is when she realizes that I had standing atop a mountain, face-to-face with the horizon, or wading in remote rivers, was a satisfaction and a peace beyond explanation.


Santo describes a piece of Trail magic, where someone is generous to through hikers. On the PCT it is water and watermelon in the dessert.


Santo describes one piece of the trail called the Lemon Squeezer. Yes, this is a real thing. See the picture on this website.


Santo is called home when his father is about to die.



12. Lena

As a single mom, Lena seemed like she was over the top on things. She measured everything Christine did and was.


TerribleSilence writes back what he has found: IS VALERIE INSIDE THE COMPOUND? Possible SERE grounds stakeout. Night vision goggles, etc., look for any suspicious movements or activity. Either the book or TerribleSilence is definitely being insane. I am wondering if Gaige wrote this book to show how easy it is to fall for strange ideas, or a conspiracy or to make believable unsupported statements. Such as TerribleSilence says that the Warden Service and the Military are in bed with each other to cover up things. Also he is making sure she does not do anything to alert the authorities by saying even calling the tip line makes her a suspect.


He sends a picture of a sign he took off of SERE warning “about do not enter”. Another clue about what happened.


Lean realizes that she is and always will be an observer, not someone who takes action.


Back to Valerie:

She escapes! And wants the security of family. But then is caught in a trap set by her captor. But she still had the determination that I simply had to stay alive.


my thru-hike had changed me—no, shown me to myself. I’d been honest, very honest. Through hikes have a tendency to do that. It reduces you to the basics-eat, hike, sleep, then repeat. Then you start knowing something about yourself and what is essential.


Another hint which will become important later on.


Her kidnapper left.



13. Lt. Bev

Conversation with a retired game warden. He centers it on SERE. She resists.


She gets reluctant cooperation from SERE.


Interview with Gregory, then a piece from the tip line.


Valerie’s journal.


I can’t grip the pen anymore. There is an NIH article on prolonged fasting-it talks about 10 days worth. As was noted earlier, Valerie has been two months with bare minimum food intake while expending a considerable amount of energy walking. The article talks about a ten day fast under controlled conditions. There did not seem to be any long term effects.


Talks about her escape.



14. Lena

TerribleSilence has gone silent.


She decides she needs to make an appearance at the dinner table-she avoids this. She is greeted by “Nice to see you, Lena,” says blind Juanita. I suspect this is the author’s attempt at humor. There are a couple of places she uses something like that. I think it is along the lines as a psychology professor of Sherri’s had a dry sense of humor and used it to see who in the class was paying attention.


At the dinner table they were discussing Presidential biographies. Warren asks: do we judge the biography by the writer or the subject? I actually used an off-shoot of this question in my own Book Group. I think it is a good one. Another person says that Sinners make for better stories. Probably true, or at least when there is tension, drama and/or action. That may go along with the sinners.



15. Lt. Bev

Ten day mark. Call from her boss, not directly discouraging, but as a check in and letting her know what is on his mind. Encouraging her to take a day from the search. They have searched 4,000 acres, about 6.25 sq miles. A lot of ground, but not much considering the area.


Mystery is fine in heaven and in poetry, but on earth, mystery signals human failure. It is the unknown which has failed to be understood.


Life does go on.


It has been awhile since Bev has been to church. God knows you are a broken sinner and loves you anyway. That is what we know as Christians. Then Gaige asks the question: without God, who forgives? Human beings are pretty unforgiving. The law certainly isn’t forgiving. Forgiveness needs a messenger. That is so true. To Christians, Jesus is that messenger and more, from God to say we are loved.



16. Lena

Lena finally gets a response from TerribleSilence’s account. Instead of him, it is his mother. TerribleSilence’s real name is Daniel Means and he has psychological problems. Currently he has been institutionalized. Daniel is 21 years old.



17. Lt. Bev

Day 11 of the search and the largest search event. Even Valerie’s husband goes out.


Bev’s mothers, Ma was a good person. Just lost. It sounded like when her husband left, she just did not have enough to take care of kids. That was left to Bev. what I’d gotten from her wasn’t really goodness as much as postures of goodness. That is sad.



18. Lena

Lena comes to a self-realization. Once you see that your daughter suffers, you must acknowledge that you are impotent and perhaps even insufficient as her mother and protector.


She has an idea about the lost hiker.



19. Lt. Bev

The least you can do for a mourning mother is give her a body. See the NPR article at the end of the references.



20. Lena

In a fit of anger, she had destroyed her computer. She uses Warren’s and is looking through the old messages. She compares photos of Valerie and Daniel. There is the clue which the author alludes to in chapters 6 and 12


Back to Valerie’s journal:

She reveals why she went on a thru-hike: My question was, When would my heart be whole again? She thinks she was only part way to resolving that question when Santo left the trail. It was on Moosilauke did she realize that she was built to feel, to help, to give. Some day my heart would be put back together, maybe missing a piece or two. But for now, love was another act I couldn’t bear to perform without the proper tools.


Have you ever hiked above the tree line? You should some day. It’s holy up there. That is so true. There is nothing between you and the sky, the sun, the moon. There is a starkness which I have not experienced anyplace else. Generally, it is a place where you can be alone. She says that Moosilauke is where she first experienced being above timberline. Looking at Google Earth, it is only the peak, not like you would see in the Sierra or Rockies.


She decides to move on from her camp.



21. Lt. Bev

Bev met with her supervisor. She thinks she is going to be asked to retire. Instead he is very uplifting and says that after working 12 days, 16 hour days, she needs a break. I wish I had a supervisor like that. She is going to see her dying mother in Massachusetts.


Tip Line conversation: Lena calls in saying they need to contact Daniel Means.



22. Lt. Bev

Talks about visiting her mother and seeing her sisters. Her sisters love Bev as the person who took care of them. Bev realizes what she needs to see is her sister’s family.


Tanya, the investigator, interviewed Daniel Means and told them where he left Valerie. Bev leaves her family and goes back to Maine. This is a four hour drive. Doesn’t she have anybody else who can conduct the search until she gets there? Turns out that everybody else is on assignment, away from the area. They are putting together a search team to come in from Crocker Mountain. That is 3.3 miles away as the crow flies. There is a road on the north side of Black Nubbe only half a mile away. Why not use that one?


How old is this book? Says it was published in 2025. Rob asks if she has her DeLorme. That is not a name I have heard for 10 years now. It made a PLB called InReach, a PLB, which is still very popular today. In 2016 DeLorme was bought by Garmin. So why would she need both the InReach and a PLB?


Regina and Badger will meet her close to Black Nubble. They are tracking at night, trying to find a scent. They find the boot which the mud sucked up. But no scent.


Way leads on to way. From the Robert Frost poem, The Road Not Taken. I think Gaige was trying to figure out how to get this poem into the book.


They find her tent and what she left behind. They find her.



25. Lt. Bev

Bev is retiring. Her mom is still alive. She redoes her home in Maine. Valerie gives Bev her journal which she kept on the Trail.


Looking up at the stars, I know quite well / That, for all they care, I can go to hell

I do not regret anything. Poem by A H Auden called The More Loving One.Gaige had quoted this once before.


She ends the book with

Here’s an idea: All emotions start out as love. Later, that love is worked on by the forces of luck and suffering.

Hate is just soured love.

Fear is wounded love.

Longing is homeless love.

Love, not pain, is the mother. Love is the taproot.

I have no regrets. I do not regret anything.

Not sure if this is sappy or what.



Author’s Note

Gerry Largay-based upon this hiker’s experience of being lost and then died after 26 days.




Evaluation:

Amity Gaige’s Heartwood main story is about the search for a lost hiker on the Appalachian Trail and her tale of survival. It is also a story of a 76 year old lady in an assisted living facility who is estranged from her daughter. Added to this, there are concerns about a Naval survival school close to the trail and a young man who has psychological problems.


The strength of the book is that she describes the problems of search and rescue pretty well. She has researched how this is done and writes a pretty compelling description. And her main character, Bev Miller, the leader of the search, is well developed.


But there are so many threads which Gaige tries to weave into the story that she weakens the account of the search. The introduction of the Naval survival school as a source of why the hiker is lost seems more a play on today’s environment of distrust than on something realistic. The part of the troubled young man is a bit disbelievable. He escorted the lost hiker 6 miles off the trail, along with how he did it without arousing attention.


Heartland is an OK read. Spending three or four hours reading it will not be a waste of your time. Just do not hope for great enlightenment.


 
Notes from my book group:

How does the book exemplify that Janet is Valerie’s heartwood? When you hear the word heartwood, what images does it bring to mind?


Have you ever thru-hiked? Where and when? What was your experience doing it? Were you the same person when you got off the trail as when you started?


Have you ever been lost? What was it like?


How realistic do you think Gaige described the search?


What skills and experiences do you need to be an experienced hiker? What should Valerie have known to avoid the situation she was in?


What danger do you think you would face on a multi-day trip? Which ones are the most likely?


loss of mental control is more dangerous than the lack of food or water. If you were lost, what emotions do you think you would need to control? What kind of thinking pattern would you need? Do you think Valerie had that mentality?


Lena thinks that She cannot bear the suggestion that her mind is unsafe. How is this similar to what Valerie was experiencing? In either situation, how can you know when you cannot trust what your mind is telling you?


Valerie wrote that being a thru hiker is not a reasonable thing. Why not? Everybody’s got a reason to hike the trail. Why do you think people thru hike? What reasons does Valerie give? Do you think Gaige understood the thru-hiker mentality?


Why does Gaige include the interviews with Santo? What did it give the story?


Throughout the book, Gaige gives little tidbits about what happened to Valerie and who it was done by. Based upon these clues, how soon did you figure out it was TerribleSilence? Were her clues helpful?


The timeline between what happened to Valerie and Daniel’s conversations with Lena seemed a bit disjointed. Were you able to piece together when the conversations and actions were happening?


Beverly Miller when she was young felt she needed to be called to something. How did she know what she was called to do? This sense of calling, what does it consist of?


Gaige writes about SERE and the distrust Daniel has towards them. Why do you think she picks on SERE as an object of distrust? How easy was it that Lena accepted Daniel’s statement about SERE? Was Daniel’s original distrust of SERE because of his psychological problems? Do you think Gaige is associating conspiracy talk with psychological issues?


Why do you think Gaige included fragments of poetry in this book?


As a throw-away line, Gaige has one of the characters in the dining room as do we judge the biography by the writer or the subject? Also, do Sinners make for better stories?


When Beverly is doing some self-inspection, she realizes that what her mother gave her wasn’t really goodness as much as postures of goodness. What is the difference? What is meant by this?


One bit of inner dialogue which Beverly has is God knows you are a broken sinner and loves you anyway. … without God, who forgives? Human beings are pretty unforgiving. The law certainly isn’t forgiving. Forgiveness needs a messenger. Discuss who forgives if there is no God? Also the thought that there needs to be a messenger of forgiveness.


What does the author want us to feel when we read this book?


How do you want your life to change because you read this book?



Many of these questions are either from or adapted from LitLovers.

Why the title of Heartwood?

Does this story work as a thriller or mystery?

Did the ending seem fitting? Satisfying? Predictable?

Which character was the most convincing? Least?

Which character did you identify with?

Which one did you dislike?

Every story has a world view. Were you able to identify this story’s world view? What was it? How did it affect the story?

In what context was religion talked about in this book?

Why do you think the author wrote this book?

What would you ask the author if you had a chance?

What “takeaways” did you have from this book?

Describe the culture talked about in the book. How is the culture described in this book different than where we live?

Talk about specific passages that struck you as significant—or interesting, profound, amusing, illuminating, disturbing, sad...?

What was memorable?

Reading Groups General Fiction Guide



OSHER Book Club Questions:

Discussion Questions

  • Valerie’s story is told partly through letters to her mother. How did this format affect your emotional connection to her? Did it feel intimate, unreliable, or both?
  • Beverly Miller approaches the search with professionalism and restraint. How does her inner life complicate the idea of a “rescuer”?
  • Lena becomes involved from afar. What does her role say about observation, intuition, and the power (or limits) of watching rather than acting?
  • Which character did you feel closest to—and did that change as the novel progressed?
  • How does the wilderness function in the novel: antagonist, mirror, refuge, or something else?
  • Valerie is an experienced hiker, yet she still gets lost. What does the book suggest about control, preparation, and vulnerability?
  • Did the novel romanticize survival, or did it strip it down to something harsher and more realistic
  • The mother-daughter relationship is central even though Valerie’s mother is largely absent in real time. How does memory stand in for presence in the novel?
  • What role does grief—personal, generational, or collective—play in the characters’ decisions?
  • How do the characters carry the past with them into the present, sometimes without realizing it?
  • The novel moves between multiple viewpoints and timelines. Did this heighten tension or slow it down for you?
  • How did Gaige’s prose style—especially in Valerie’s sections—shape your reading experience?
  • Were there moments where what was unsaid felt more important than what was explicit?
  • What does Heartwood suggest about connection—between people, between humans and nature, and across distance?
  • The search for Valerie involves strangers deeply invested in someone they don’t truly know. What motivates that kind of commitment?
  • How does the novel reflect post-pandemic ideas of isolation, endurance, or reevaluating one’s life?
  • What do you think the title Heartwood ultimately represents?
  • Did the ending feel earned? Why or why not?
  • What stayed with you after finishing the book—a scene, a line, a feeling?
  • Who would you recommend this book to, and what would you tell them it’s really about?
  • In what ways do memory and grief influence the characters’ actions?
  • How do past experiences quietly surface in the present throughout the novel?
  • Why do people become deeply invested in searching for someone they don’t know personally?
  • How does the novel reflect themes of isolation, endurance, or reevaluating life after trauma?
  • Did the ending feel satisfying or unsettling? Why?
  • What image, scene, or line stayed with you after finishing the book?
  • How would you describe this novel to someone deciding whether to read it?
  • One word to describe how the book made you feel
  • A passage that resonated with you
  • Would you survive? What choice Valerie made would you have handled differently?

From Amity Gaige DISCUSSION QUESTIONS on Simon&Schuster’s web site:

1. Each of the three main characters in Heartwood find solace in nature. Lena loves birdwatching and foraging. For Valerie, long-distance hiking makes her feel “whole.” Bev thinks of the backcountry as her “mother.” When was the last time you really felt connected to nature?

2. Talk about how you felt as Valerie described her lostness. What do you think you would feel or do if you became lost in the outdoors?

3. Valerie writes letters to her mother while she is lost in the woods. Who would you write to and what would you want them to know?

4. What do you think about the novel’s connection between lostness and being motherless?

5. For many readers, Santo is a surprising favorite character. What did you think about his role in the investigation and his friendships with Valerie and Cody the warden?

6. Heartwood is as much about being lost as it is about being found. What times in your life have you been “lost” emotionally, spiritually, or psychologically, and who rescued you?

7. Heartwood was written during the pandemic and Lena was inspired by how difficult quarantine was for older people. Did reading Heartwood remind you of that difficult time? And was there anything you turned to, like reading, internet-sleuthing or hiking, that helped you get through it?

8. Though there are true stories of people going missing while hiking, there is also a vibrant and supportive trail community. The book is in many ways a celebration of the American wilderness. Did reading Heartwood make you want to hike the Appalachian Trail?



New Words:
  • Ativan: a prescription medication belonging to the benzodiazepine class, used primarily to treat anxiety disorders, acute agitation, and seizures
  • Hasty Team: a small, highly trained, and fast-moving search and rescue (SAR) unit dispatched immediately to high-probability areas to locate missing persons or evidence
  • Inamorato: a person's male lover
  • Oeuvre: the works of a painter, composer, or author regarded collectively
  • Slattern: an untidy, slovenly woman
  • Cytologist: one specializing in the study of cells; a pathologist using cytological techniques in the differential diagnosis of neoplasms.
  • sui generis: unique
  • Lugubriousness: especially : exaggeratedly or affectedly mournful
  • Logomania: abnormal talkativeness
Book References:
  • My Side of the Mountain by Jean Craighead George
  • Alexander Hamilton by Ron Chernow
  • When You Find My Body byD. Dauphinee
  • When I Fell from the Sky by Juliane Koepcke
  • Lost on a Mountain in Maine by Donn Fendler
  • The Red and the Black by Stendhal


Good Quotes:
  • First Line: Dear Mother, You used to call me Sparrow
  • Last Line: I do not regret anything
  • Up here, we tend to think of being lost as something you can be good at. Chp 1 Lt Bev
  • loss of mental control is more dangerous than the lack of food or water. Chp 1 Lt Bev
  • I don’t know which scares me more—being found by him, or being found by no one. Chp 3 Lt Bev
  • without books, there was nothing but time. Chp 4 Lena

References: