Basic Information:
Author:
Moshe A. Milvesky
Edition:
ePub on Overdrive from the Fresno County Library
Publisher:
Wiley
ISBN:
1118291530 (ISBN13: 9781118291535
Start
Date: November 13, 2019
Read
Date: November 23, 2019
210
pages
Genre:
Personal Growth, Retirement
Language
Warning: None
Rated
Overall: 3 out of 5
Synopsis (Caution: Spoiler Alert-Jump to Thoughts):
Milvesky
has seven equations which he is interested in sharing concerning
retirement preparedness and living it. These are all financial. He
goes through and talks about the uses of each, explains their
origins, and talks about the background authority of each one-not
necessarily the one who came up with the equation.
- How long will I spend in retirement (Gompertz)
- Is a pension annuity worth it? (Halley)
- What is a proper spending rate? (Fisher)
- How much in risky stocks versus safe cash? (Samuelson)
- What is your financial legacy today? (Huebner)
- Is my current plan sustainable? (Kolmogorov)
Expectations:
- Date Became Aware of Book: November 13, 2019
- How come do I want to read this book: I was skimming through the Fresno’s library for something to read and came across this title sounded interesting
- What do I think I will get out of it? Maybe some quantitative means to meaure how I am doing in my retirement, financially.
Thoughts:
Notations
used in equations:
Notation | Meaning | Formula’s Used |
ax
|
The
value of a $1 per year for life pension annuity for a person x
years old
|
III |
b |
the
dispersion coefficient of human
life in years, usually 9.5 years
|
II |
c |
the
amount you would like to spend or consume above and beyond any
retirement pension you might receive
|
I
|
FC
|
Financial
Capital accumalated (dollars)
|
V |
HC
|
value
of Human Capital, i.e., expected is how much you expect to earn
until retirement. It should be in terms of present value.
|
V |
i
|
III, VI | |
iPx
|
survival
probability (from
chaper 2)
|
III, VI |
ln(px)
|
survival
probability for one year, where x=the age
|
IV |
m |
modal
value of human life. Usually 87.5 years. Given your group, the
most like age you will die.
|
II |
p | Probability that you will live to a given age | II |
P
|
Prbability
of ruin (spending will outrun the money
|
VII |
qx
|
Probability
of dying
|
III(?), VI |
r |
interest
rate your nest egg is earning while being depleted. Need to assume
a flat line interest.
IV-should
be after inflation
V-interest
rates from safest investments, such as savings, ... (I
show this mistakenly as ρ-rho)
|
I, IV, V, VI |
R
|
Periodic
interest rate
|
III, VI |
t | Years nest egg will last | I |
T | Retirement time | VII |
t |
the
number of years you might still live in years
|
II |
W |
size
of the nest egg
|
I
|
w
|
Amount
of money relative to what you are planning on spending
(Money/spending)
|
VII |
x |
current
age in years
|
II, III |
γ
|
risk
aversion-how long do you think you really are going to live. The
higher the value, the less risk you are willing to take on.
|
IV, V |
λ
|
Instantaneous
force of mortality. When it is over time , it is λt
|
VII |
μ
|
rate
at which you/experts think stocks will grow over time. This is in
percent. Historically it is 7%
|
V, VII |
ρ
|
subjective
discount rate-how patient you are to spend
|
IV |
σ
|
volatility
pf stocks. For a well diversified portfolio, it has been
historically around 20%
|
V |
ψ
|
The
amount in dollars is about how much you should risk
|
V |
Introduction:
An Equation Can't Predict Your Future . . .But It Can Help You Plan
for It
Chapter
1: How Long Will My Number Last? Equation #1: Leonardo Fibonacci
(1170–1250)
- This formula is not concerned with preserving principal, only when using the principal for living expenses-high long will it last?
- Milvesky notes that you can solve for any of the three variable, not just how long it will last. Such as, if you live 30 years and want $5,000 income from a 3% interest rate, you can see how big of an amount you would need to start with.
- See the seventh equation for a more robust solution than this first one.
Chapter
2: How Long Will I Spend in Retirement? Equation #2: Benjamin
Gompertz (1779–1865)
Wikipedia's version of Gompertz' equation |
- Gompertz law of mortality – gives an idea of how long a person will probably live given their current age. From Wikipedia, it states The Gompertz–Makeham law states that the human death rate is the sum of an age-dependent component (the Gompertz function, named after Benjamin Gompertz),[1] which increases exponentially with age[2] and an age-independent component (the Makeham term, named after William Makeham).[3] In a protected environment where external causes of death are rare (laboratory conditions, low mortality countries, etc.), the age-independent mortality component is often negligible. In this case the formula simplifies to a Gompertz law of mortality. In 1825, Benjamin Gompertz proposed an exponential increase in death rates with age.
- This formula, allows a person to plan for his financial future for as long as his expected life span is.
- For mortaily figures, you can look at www.mortality.org
Chapter
3: Is a Pension Annuity Worth It? Equation #3: Edmond Halley
(1656–1742)
DB=Defined
Benefit Plan-where a set amount will be paid for your pension
DC=Defined
Contribution-offeres projections, hopes and expectations, no pomises.
- The above equation will tell you what a DB/pension is worth and how much it should cost to aquire one which is an equavalent. From this you can tell if it is better to take a lump sum or take the DB.
- People who take out life insurance have a tendency to live longer
- When it comes to which is right, an equation or the market, the market is always right.
Chapter
4: What Is a Proper Spending Rate? Equation #4: Irving Fisher
(1867–1947)
- Left side of the equation is telling us how to change our buying behavior as we age.
- The right side is what affcts our buying behavior.
- How do rational consumers formulate a spending plan? That is the thrurst of this equation.
- Fisher was no infalliable. Even when the Great Crash of 1929 occurred, he was saying the stock market would rebound quickly. Also he was a fan of Eugenics to correct the problems of society.
Chapter
5: How Much in Risky Stocks versus Safe Cash? Equation #5: Paul
Samuelson (1915–2009)
- It is not time per se which is a factor in this equation, but a person’s preferences/attitude towards risk.
Chapter
6: What Is Your Financial Legacy Today? Equation #6: Solomon S.
Huebner (1882–1964)
- The idea here is that while people are dependent on you how much is a good amount to leave for those who are left behind. Once you’ve retired, should you-and can you actually afford to-leave them anything by still paying for an expensive life insurance policy?
- Should you have term or whole life? Along that lines, does it make sense to have life annuities?
Chapter
7: Is My Current Plan Sustainable? Equation #7: Andrei N. Kolmogorov
(1903–1987)
He starts out summarizing what was covered:
- Chp 1: linking the fixed spending rate with a fixed interest to figure out how long your money will last
- Chp 2: Life expectancy is somewhat randomn. What is the probable age of passing?
- Chp 3: Value of pension annuity
- Chp 4: Quantifying the effects of patience in spending at a constant rate vs some longevity risks
- Chp 5: Hw to think about assest allocation as age and time
- Chp 6: What is the value of a death benefit?
- Chp 7: What is the probablility that your retirement plan can be sustained
- dollar-vauled withdrawl rate
- The assumption with probability is that there is a smooth line, not discrete stages of change.
- Gambler’s ruin problem
Conclusion:
Controversies, Omissions and Concluding Thoughts 175
Appendix:
Crash Course on Natural and Unnatural Logarithms 179
Evaluation:
This
is not a book for everybody. It is for those who want to quantify
what their financial retirement will look like. Even then, these are
not easy formulas. Stephen Hawking said that for each equation in a
book, you halve its sales. With seven of them, Milvesky may have
troubles having this book be profitable,
Milvesky
gives seven formulas ranging from a good algebra level formula to
calculus. He examines probabilities on life expectancy, how much of
my assets can I spend and when, as well as how should my assests be
invested. On the later it is more conservatively vs aggressively,
This is not a book you pick up to plan your retirement, but a book to
help you understand if you are on the right track. It also is a book
of probabilities than definites. It gives you the tools to say that
things look like you are coming out OK vs you are going to be OK-it
is important to know that distinction.
Milvesky
does a good job of giving examples of how to use the forumlas. He
also goes through the people behind them as well. But I you really do
need to be the type of person who enjoys equations in order to get
through the book.
Book References:
- Liber Abaci by Leondardo Pisano Fibonacci (2003 translation from Latin by Laurence Sigler)
- The Nunmber by Lee Eisenberg
- Principles by Isaac Newton (Halley assisted in getting this book published)
- Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen
- The History of Fish (De Historia Piscium) by Francis Willughby
- The Theory of Interest: As Determined by Impatience to Spend Income and Opportunity to Invest It by Irving Fisher
- The Theory of Interest by Irving Fisher
- Stocks for the Long Run by Jeremy Siegel
- Economics by Paul Samuelson
- General Theory by John Maynard Keynes
- The Teacher Who Changed an Industry by Mildred Stone
- War and Peave by Leo Tolstoy
- Aryabhatiya by Aryabhata
- The Improbable Origins of Modern Wall Street by Peter Bernstein
Good Quotes:
- First Line: Most books about retirement planning are written as guides, instruction manuals or “how-to” books.
- Last Line: It [e] truly is a remarkable number, and justifiably embedded in the DNA of the most important equations for retirement.
- Introduction: An Equation Can't Predict Your Future . . .But It Can Help You Plan for It
- Chapter 1: How Long Will My Number Last? Equation #1: Leonardo Fibonacci (1170–1250)
- Chapter 2: How Long Will I Spend in Retirement? Equation #2: Benjamin Gompertz (1779–1865)
- Chapter 3: Is a Pension Annuity Worth It? Equation #3: Edmond Halley (1656–1742)
- Chapter 4: What Is a Proper Spending Rate? Equation #4: Irving Fisher (1867–1947)
- Chapter 5: How Much in Risky Stocks versus Safe Cash? Equation #5: Paul Samuelson (1915–2009)
- Chapter 6: What Is Your Financial Legacy Today? Equation #6: Solomon S. Huebner (1882–1964)
- Chapter 7: Is My Current Plan Sustainable? Equation #7: Andrei N. Kolmogorov (1903–1987)
- Conclusion: Controversies, Omissions and Concluding Thoughts
- Appendix: Crash Course on Natural and Unnatural Logarithms
- References and Sources
- Acknowledgments
- About the Author
- Short Poem by Maya Milevsky (age 11)
- Index
References:
- Author's Web Site
- Wikipedia-Author
- Amazon-Book
- Amazon-Author
- GoodReads-Book
- GoodReads-Author
- Semantics Scholar paper where the author has a paper showing the derivation of the equations
- Think Advisor – Review
- Business Insider interview
- Morningstar – discussion
No comments:
Post a Comment